Rating U
Length 1h21
Release 15.06.1951
Director Charles Crichton
About Henry, a shy bank clerk in charge of gold bullions, dreams of leading an opulent life. Soon, he comes in contact with a foundry owner, Alfred. Both plan to smuggle gold out of the bank.
Moon: no moon sighting
Where to Watch: 4OD
Trailer:
The Good
Alec Guinness once again showing his comedic skills as by-the-book banker who comes up with what he believes to be the perfect plan to steal the gold he’s spent the last 20 years protecting.
Just wait for the robbery to get going and how Holland paints himself as the victim; it’s physical comedy that you can clearly see influenced both Rowan Atkinson and John Cleese.
The plot is solid and the theft has the approval of the Bank of England; they are the ones who came up with it after all. There’s clear cause and effect in play and it makes for a satisfying story.
The use of the bookend narrative doesn’t seem to work as well at first, however it does pay off when the credits begin to role.
Sid James in a pre-Carry On role shows exactly why he became the lead of that franchise. His comic timing and course accents it the perfect balance to Guinness’ upper-middle class stiff upper lip.
The Bad
The work based discussions we overhear and the opinions based on Holland do not fit within the narrative and one scene contradicts the other.
Firstly, Holland wasn’t present to be able to talk about these conversations and therefore it makes the storytelling device of the book ended narration stupid.
Secondly, the first scene tells us Holland will never be promoted and not well liked. The scene right before the robbery Holland is fighting a promotion we’ve been told he’d never get.
The Ugly
The latter part of the film is rather clunky. Almost as if the mob had not thought past the stealing of the gold. Which is ridiculous as Holland clearly says it was getting it out of the country that was the sticking point.
However, the robbery was so precise to the point that even the arrest of Pendlebury seemed planned and it’s a stark contrast to the comedy of errors that happen from Paris onwards.
Final Thoughts
It was a fair and harmless watch for a week-day afternoon, but it wasn’t the great film I was expecting it to be.
The Queens of Geekdom 